Lyla is now in beta testing. Join the waitlist here >
5 min read

Will AI Writers Ever Replace Human Writers? (Probably Not)

A robot firing a human
Yes. This image was generated by AI ;)

In just the last few months, the rise of generative AI and its surprising capabilities has led to concerns about job displacement.

Through the last 2 decades, as technology has advanced, many professions have been impacted by automation, leaving workers questioning the future of their careers and their livelihoods.

One profession that finds itself at the center of the obsolescence discussion is writing (of pretty much any kind).

With AI-powered tools capable of generating hundreds of high quality blog posts in minutes or movie scripts in seconds, it's natural for writers to worry.

But before anyone jumps to conclusions, take a deep breath and let's explore this topic with a balanced perspective.

While AI has made significant advancements in generating content quickly and efficiently, there are still essential aspects of writing that cannot be replicated by machines.

Is AI Creative?

Creativity is often cited as a fundamental skill unique to humans. It involves coming up with novel and valuable ideas—an eureka moment that sets humans apart from machines.

But can AI truly replicate creativity? Well, the answer is yes AND no. AI can assist with and augment a human writer's creativity.

Machines can now generate innovative designs using generative design software combined with 3D printing technology. These designs often mimic natural forms found in the world, surpassing what human designers might conceive.

Similarly, AI algorithms can compose music in almost any style suggested to them. While listeners may dismiss computer-generated music when they know its origin, they often find it equally evocative and beautiful when unaware.

However, there are areas where machines fall short. When it comes to writing lyrics or longer-form prose that touch upon the human condition, computers produce gibberish or nonsensical text that lacks insight into our collective experiences.

Computers lack a deep understanding of human emotions or the ability to reflect them back to us effectively.

The Intuition of the Native Speaker

This limitation can be attributed to what linguistics refer to as "the intuition of the native speaker."

Native speakers possess an innate understanding of their language—the ability to distinguish between grammatically correct sentences and poorly constructed ones with ease.

Similarly, humans possess a "native speaker's intuition" when it comes to the complexities of the human condition and societal dynamics. This intuition is challenging to convey successfully to even sophisticated AI systems.

Lack of Soul

As I experimented with various AI writing tools myself—requesting things like Twitter threads on specific topics—I found their outputs surprisingly good but ultimately generic in nature.

The absence of soulful words and phrases with real emotional impact became apparent; even when an AI-generated piece seemed seamless at first glance, it lacked depth upon closer examination.

While AI is amazing at generating ideas or even providing drafts for inspiration or further development by humans with creativity skills honed over years or even decades – at this stage – it cannot replicate genuine creative originality.

Critics argue that AI copywriting tools, like ChatGPT and, pose a significant threat to copywriters because these tools can generate large volumes of content quickly. However, a good majority of AI generated content falls into generic and unremarkable territory—a far cry from what skilled copywriters produce.

Most businesses seek out copywriters for their unique ability to craft engaging and persuasive messages that resonate with consumers on a personal level.

The human touch is what sets great copy apart from its machine-generated counterparts.

The Human Element

True creative writing involves more than just assembling words according to predefined formulas or templates.

It requires a deep understanding of the human experience, the ability to illuminate various aspects of life and society, and the power to evoke emotions and connections within readers.

Computers lack human experiences; they have not evolved in our world or experienced life alongside us.

They are exceptional at mimicking certain aspects of writing based on predefined rules or patterns, but when it comes to truly understanding and reflecting the complexities of the human condition or delivering a unique perspective effectively, they fall short.

Creative writers and lyricists possess an intuition about the human condition that comes from years of observation, reflection, and empathy.

They have an innate understanding that allows them to craft prose or lyrics that resonate with readers on a deep level.

This fundamental aspect is what makes their writing irreplaceable; it reflects genuine human emotions and perspectives.

Writer's Don't Just Write

Writing is merely one aspect of comprehensive marketing strategies. Copywriters often have multifaceted roles encompassing various skills beyond writing alone.

The ability to run successful email marketing programs, analyze data, devise strategies, measure ROI, oversee automations, optimize conversion rates—these are all areas where machines cannot compete with human intellect.

In addition, the ability to determine a client's specific needs, devise marketing strategies, exceptional understanding of different channels like email marketing, social media platforms, search engine optimization adds value derived from years of experience. AI bots could never replicate such integrative engagements.

While concerns about job displacement are valid in many industries undergoing automation advancements, the fear remains unfounded for skilled writers who continually upskill themselves and expand their expertise beyond traditional writing tasks alone.

For those at the top of their profession who understand marketing at a deeper level—and have developed the ability to guide brands towards success through exceptional communication—the future remains bright.

And while there are concerns about the impact of AI on the writing industry, it is important to recognize that skilled writers have always adapted to changing technologies throughout history.

As with any transformative technology advancement from typewriters to computers and word processors, writing professionals found ways not only integrate new tools into their workflow but also uncover novel possibilities these advancements facilitated.

AI is an Ally, Not a Conqueror

Rather than viewing AI as a threat in terms of redundancy or replacement within the writing industry – writers can harness these technologies as powerful creative aids in generating ideas while still retaining their own unique human touch. Which is of tremendous value in an era where speed is key.

The ability to take AI-generated content as inspiration or draft material and then craft it into truly impactful prose separates professional writers from mere producers of text.

As mentioned before, there have been a few transformative inventions in history that have propelled the industry into the future, the invention of paper, typewriters, computers and now AI assisted writing.

Professional writers understand that their expertise lies not just in generating text, but in shaping it with their own creative vision. By harnessing the capabilities of AI while retaining their individuality, writers can continue to thrive in the ever-evolving landscape of writing and communication.

Final Thoughts

While AI writing undoubtedly offers impressive capabilities for generating written content with great speed and efficiency, its limitations become apparent when one examines the essence of truly creative writing. That ability to connect with readers on a deep emotional level through insightful reflections on the human condition.

Experts believe it will take significant advances in technology before AI can genuinely replicate this crucial aspect of writing.

Writers need not fear obsolescence; instead they should embrace AI as a valuable tool and upskill themselves in other areas that complement their craft.

By expanding their expertise beyond mere word-smithing—into strategy development leveraging sophisticated software tools gaining insights into market dynamics—they can remain indispensable partners for businesses seeking comprehensive marketing solutions.

In an era where technology continues to evolve rapidly – writers who nurture their creative talents while harnessing emerging tools stand at the forefront of success rather than being displaced by technological advancements.

A future where AI completely replaces human writers remains distant, if it ever arrives at all. So, let us continue to write unique stories, inspire emotions, and shape the world with our words – for no AI can replicate the soulful spirit of human creativity.

Subscribe: Want to learn how to market your business and 10x your productivity using AI? Subscribe to our weekly email and we'll show you how! Featuring our newest AI shortcuts, review of the newest AI tools and special member only deals when they become available.